Piper Twin Comanche Cost of Ownership

Complete financial analysis of owning and operating the classic twin-engine Piper Twin Comanche aircraft

Covering purchase prices, insurance, fuel, maintenance, and total annual operating costs for 2025

The Piper Twin Comanche: Affordable Twin-Engine Performance

The Piper Twin Comanche represents one of the most economical ways to gain twin-engine experience and capability. Produced from 1963 to 1972, the Twin Comanche features two Lycoming IO-320 engines producing 160 horsepower each, offering redundancy, better altitude performance, and improved safety margins compared to single-engine aircraft. With purchase prices ranging from $99,000 to $235,000 on the used market, the Twin Comanche provides an affordable entry point into twin-engine ownership for qualified pilots.

While the aircraft is 50+ years old, well-maintained examples remain reliable workhorses for cross-country flying and personal transportation. The twin-engine configuration requires higher pilot qualifications (multi-engine rating mandatory) and significantly higher operating costs than comparable single-engine aircraft, but many owners consider the improved safety and performance worth the investment.

Why Pilots Choose the Twin Comanche

Twin-engine redundancy and improved performance at altitude attract safety-conscious pilots. The Twin Comanche's relatively low purchase price ($165,000 average) makes it accessible compared to newer twins. Proven reliability with 160-HP Lycoming engines, benign handling characteristics, and established owner community provide confidence. Trade-offs include higher operating costs (16-17 GPH fuel burn), complex systems requiring multi-engine rating, and vintage aircraft maintenance challenges typical of 50+ year old airframes.

Purchase Price: What You'll Pay

Used Aircraft Pricing by Era

Early Production (1963-1965): $99,000-$145,000 - PA-30 models with original IO-320 engines, basic avionics, lower resale appeal but lower purchase price
Mid Production (1965-1968): $130,000-$185,000 - PA-30B variants with improved systems, better handling characteristics, and more modern configurations
Late Production (1969-1972): $150,000-$235,000 - PA-39 Turbo models with enhanced performance, better avionics options, and premium features
Restored/Premium Examples: $180,000-$280,000 - Factory restorations, modern avionics packages (Garmin G1000 NXi), and exceptional condition aircraft commanding premium pricing

Key Price Factors

Total Airframe Hours: Each 1,000 hours typically reduces value by $3,000-$5,000 depending on maintenance quality and engine reserve status
Engine Hours Until Major Overhaul: Engines approaching TBO (2,000 hours) significantly reduce resale value; recent overhauls command 10-15% premium pricing
Avionics Package: Modern glass cockpit (Garmin G1000 NXi, GarminPilot) adds $20,000-$40,000 to value; basic VFR avionics reduces value by $15,000-$25,000
Maintenance History: Complete logbooks and regular maintenance records can command 5-10% premium; deferred maintenance can reduce value 15-20%
Turbocharging: PA-30C and PA-39 turbo variants command 10-15% premiums over naturally-aspirated models due to high-altitude capability

Financing a Twin Comanche

Down Payment Requirements

Most aircraft lenders require 20-30% down payment for Piper Twin Comanche aircraft. For a $165,000 purchase price:

20% Down: $33,000 down, $132,000 financed (typical for excellent credit and pilot qualifications)
25% Down: $41,250 down, $123,750 financed (most common scenario for qualified applicants)
30% Down: $49,500 down, $115,500 financed (for marginal credit or limited experience)

Loan Terms and Rates

Aircraft loan terms for Piper Twin Comanche typically range from 10-15 years at 6-8% interest rates (varies by credit score and pilot experience):

10-Year Term at 6.5%: $1,530/month on $123,750 financed ($18,360/year)
12-Year Term at 7%: $1,318/month on $123,750 financed ($15,816/year)
15-Year Term at 7.5%: $1,125/month on $123,750 financed ($13,500/year)

Insurance Costs

Liability and Hull Coverage

Insurance for the Piper Twin Comanche varies significantly based on pilot qualifications. Qualified pilots (1,500+ total hours, 500 multi-engine hours, 500 retractable gear hours) pay substantially less than less-experienced pilots:

Liability Only ($1M coverage) - Qualified Pilot: $850-$1,050 annually
Liability Only ($1M coverage) - Less Qualified Pilot: $1,100-$1,375 annually
Liability + Hull ($1M/$46K) - Qualified Pilot: $1,975-$2,380 annually
Liability + Hull ($1M/$46K) - Less Qualified Pilot: $2,990-$3,860 annually
Typical Full Coverage (estimated $125K hull): $2,500-$4,000 annually depending on experience

Twin-engine aircraft insurance is significantly higher than comparable single-engine aircraft due to engine-out scenarios and additional complexity. Building multi-engine experience and maintaining a clean flying record helps reduce premiums substantially.

Fuel and Operating Costs

Fuel Consumption

The Piper Twin Comanche with twin Lycoming IO-320 engines burns approximately 16-17.2 gallons per hour at 75% power cruise settings. At current fuel prices:

At $6.00/gallon: $96-$103 per hour in fuel costs
At $6.50/gallon: $104-$112 per hour in fuel costs
At $7.00/gallon: $112-$120 per hour in fuel costs

Fuel burn depends on cruise altitude, power settings, and weather conditions. Operating both engines increases fuel consumption compared to single-engine aircraft, but twin-engine redundancy provides safety benefits that many owners value.

Maintenance and Reserves

Hourly Maintenance: $29.25 per flight hour (typical shop labor and parts)
Engine Reserve (Major Overhaul): $18.20 per flight hour for two engines with 2,000-hour TBO
Oil and Consumables: $3.95 per flight hour
Annual Inspection: $1,950 (typical; catch-up inspections can exceed $5,000-$10,000 for deferred maintenance)
Propeller Reserves: $2-$5 per flight hour (depending on propeller condition and overhaul interval)

Hourly Variable Costs

Fuel: $96-$120 per hour
Hourly Maintenance: $29.25 per hour
Engine Reserve: $18.20 per hour
Oil and Consumables: $3.95 per hour
Total Variable Costs: $147-$171 per hour

Fixed Annual Ownership Costs

Hangar/Tie-down: $1,200-$2,500 per year (hangar protects valuable twin investment; twins generally require larger hangars)
Insurance (average): $2,500-$3,500 per year (liability and hull for qualified pilot)
Annual Inspection: $1,950 per year (mandatory)
Aircraft Registration: $19 per year (FAA renewal)
Accessories/Misc: $300-$500 per year (lights, batteries, oxygen, etc.)

Total Fixed Annual Costs: Approximately $6,000-$8,500 per year

Comprehensive Annual Ownership Examples

Scenario 1: 100 Flight Hours/Year

Loan payment: $1,318/month ($15,816/year) - 12-year term at 7%
Fixed costs: $6,750
Fuel (100 hours × $108/hr): $10,800
Maintenance (100 hours × $29.25): $2,925
Engine reserve (100 hours × $18.20): $1,820
Oil/consumables (100 hours × $3.95): $395
Annual inspection: $1,950
Total Annual Cost: $40,456
Cost Per Flight Hour: $405

Scenario 2: 150 Flight Hours/Year

Loan payment: $1,318/month ($15,816/year) - 12-year term at 7%
Fixed costs: $6,750
Fuel (150 hours × $108/hr): $16,200
Maintenance (150 hours × $29.25): $4,388
Engine reserve (150 hours × $18.20): $2,730
Oil/consumables (150 hours × $3.95): $593
Annual inspection: $1,950
Total Annual Cost: $48,427
Cost Per Flight Hour: $323

Scenario 3: 200 Flight Hours/Year

Loan payment: $1,318/month ($15,816/year) - 12-year term at 7%
Fixed costs: $6,750
Fuel (200 hours × $108/hr): $21,600
Maintenance (200 hours × $29.25): $5,850
Engine reserve (200 hours × $18.20): $3,640
Oil/consumables (200 hours × $3.95): $790
Annual inspection: $1,950
Total Annual Cost: $56,396
Cost Per Flight Hour: $282

Twin Comanche vs. Comparable Aircraft

Twin Comanche vs. Beechcraft Baron 55

The Beechcraft Baron 55 is significantly more expensive ($250,000 average) but offers better performance, pressurization options on some models, and stronger resale value. The Twin Comanche provides an affordable entry into twin ownership with lower purchase price ($165,000), similar fuel burn (25-27 GPH for Baron vs. 16-17 GPH Twin Comanche), but lower performance. Baron buyers pay a 50% premium for improved payload, speed, and reliability; Twin Comanche owners accept vintage aircraft trade-offs for affordability.

Twin Comanche vs. Piper Seneca V

The Piper Seneca V ($500,000) is a modern pressurized twin with glass cockpit avionics and superior performance at altitude. The Twin Comanche costs significantly less but is 50+ years old, non-pressurized, and requires more maintenance. The Seneca burns similar fuel (24-28 GPH), costs $300,000+ more to purchase, but offers modern avionics, pressurization, and IFR capability. Twin Comanche owners choose 1960s technology for budget flexibility; Seneca owners invest in modern capability.

Twin Comanche vs. Single-Engine Alternatives (Mooney M20 Ovation)

A comparable single-engine aircraft like the Mooney M20 Ovation costs $350,000 but burns only 10 GPH at cruise and carries similar 4-5 occupants at comparable speeds (160 knots vs. 165 for Twin Comanche). Operating costs are dramatically lower ($200/hour vs. $280/hour for Twin), but the single-engine option lacks redundancy and twin-engine safety margins. Twin Comanche owners accept 40% higher operating costs for twin-engine confidence; Ovation owners optimize for economy and performance.

Is Twin Comanche Ownership Worth It?

Twin Comanche ownership makes sense for pilots prioritizing twin-engine redundancy and experience above pure operating economy. The $165,000 purchase price and $280/hour operating costs (at 200 hours annually) provide affordable access to twin ownership compared to newer light twins like the Baron or Seneca. However, the 50+ year old airframe requires committed maintenance, and the vintage technology means no pressurization, basic avionics, and specialized mechanic availability in some regions.

The aircraft excels for cross-country missions where twin-engine reliability and performance matter. It's suitable for pilots with multi-engine ratings and 500+ hours multi-engine experience. Those seeking modern avionics, pressurization, or maximum comfort should consider newer alternatives. Twin Comanche ownership is best for experienced multi-engine pilots willing to embrace vintage aircraft realities for cost-effective twin capability.

Next Steps to Twin Comanche Ownership

Obtain Multi-Engine Rating: Earn your multi-engine rating (typically 10-20 flight hours) with a qualified CFI-MEL instructor before purchasing any twin aircraft
Build Multi-Engine Experience: Accumulate 50-100 hours in twin-engine aircraft (rental or under shared ownership) to build proficiency before committing to purchase
Find Your Aircraft: Search trade-a-plane.com, controller.com, and aviation brokers for available Twin Comanche examples; inspect at least 3-5 candidates before deciding
Pre-Purchase Inspection: Hire a qualified A&P mechanic to perform thorough pre-purchase inspection; budget $2,000-$4,000 for professional evaluation
Arrange Financing: Contact aircraft lenders (regional banks, specialized aviation finance companies) 60-90 days before purchase to pre-qualify for $100,000-$150,000 loan
Secure Insurance Quotes: Obtain insurance quotes (BWI Aviation, AOPA Insurance, Falcon Insurance) before purchase; verify your qualifications align with quoted rates
Arrange Hangar/Tie-down: Secure permanent hangar space or tie-down location before taking delivery to protect your investment
Complete Transition Training: Invest in 10-20 hours of type-specific transition training with a Twin Comanche experienced instructor before solo operations

Sources and Citations

PlanePhD (2025). "PIPER PA-30B Twin Comanche - Specifications, Performance, Operating cost, Valuation" - Comprehensive aircraft valuation and operating cost data for 1965-1968 Twin Comanche models. Retrieved from https://planephd.com/wizard/details/529/PIPER-PA-30B-Twin-Comanche-specifications-performance-operating-cost-valuation
BWI Aviation Insurance (2025). "Piper Twin Comanche Insurance Cost" - Current insurance premium data by pilot qualifications for liability and hull coverage. Retrieved from https://bwifly.com/piper-twin-comanche-insurance-cost/
AVweb (2024). "Piper Twin Comanche" - Aircraft systems, performance characteristics, and operational experience from experienced aviation journalists. Retrieved from https://avweb.com/features/piper-twin-comanche/
Aviation Consumer (2025). "Piper Twin Comanche - Used Aircraft Guide" - Detailed maintenance, reliability, and ownership cost analysis for used Twin Comanche aircraft. Retrieved from https://aviationconsumer.com/used-aircraft-guide/piper-twin-comanche-3/
AOPA (2025). "Piper Twin Comanche Fact Sheet" - Official aircraft specifications, performance data, and industry recommendations from Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association. Retrieved from https://www.aopa.org/go-fly/aircraft-and-ownership/aircraft-fact-sheets/piper-twin-comanche

Disclaimer: This article reflects market conditions as of October 2025. Aircraft prices, insurance costs, and fuel prices fluctuate based on market conditions, location, and individual circumstances. Consult with aviation lenders, insurance brokers, and aircraft mechanics for personalized quotes. The information provided is for educational purposes and does not constitute financial advice. Always conduct thorough due diligence and professional inspections before purchasing any aircraft.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a Piper Twin Comanche cost?

A used Piper Twin Comanche typically costs $99,000-$235,000 depending on model year and condition. Early models (1963-1965) average $128,000, while later PA-30B variants (1965-1968) average around $165,000 as of 2025. The earlier models generally cost less to purchase but have higher fuel consumption and older avionics, whereas later models with turbocharging offer better performance at slightly higher prices.

What are the annual operating costs for a Twin Comanche?

Total annual operating costs for a Piper Twin Comanche range from $24,000-$26,000 when flying 100-150 hours per year. This includes fuel ($4,000-$6,000), maintenance ($2,500-$3,000), engine reserves ($1,200-$1,600), insurance ($2,500-$4,000), annual inspection ($1,950), and fixed costs like hangar/tie-down ($1,200-$2,500). Ownership costs per flight hour typically range from $160-$200 depending on utilization and fuel prices.

How much fuel does a Twin Comanche burn?

A Piper Twin Comanche burns approximately 16-17.2 gallons per hour at cruise settings (75% power). At current fuel prices ($6-$7 per gallon), hourly fuel costs range from $96-$120. The twin Lycoming IO-320 engines (160 HP each) are reliable and efficient for a light twin, with TBO of 2,000 hours per engine. Fuel consumption can vary based on altitude, weather, and cruise power settings.

Is financing available for a Piper Twin Comanche?

Yes, financing is available for Piper Twin Comanche aircraft, though terms are more restrictive than newer aircraft. Most lenders require 20-30% down payment, offer 10-15 year terms at 6-8% interest rates. For a $150,000 Twin Comanche with 25% down ($37,500), expect monthly loan payments around $1,100-$1,300 over 12-15 years. Credit score, pilot experience, and total airframe hours affect lending terms.

What insurance costs should I expect?

Insurance for a Piper Twin Comanche ranges from $850-$3,860 annually depending on pilot qualifications and coverage type. Qualified pilots (1,500+ total hours, 500 multi-engine hours) with liability-only coverage pay $850-$1,050/year. Comprehensive liability and hull coverage ($1M/$46K) costs qualified pilots $1,975-$2,380/year and less-qualified pilots $2,990-$3,860/year. Twin-engine insurance is significantly higher than single-engine aircraft due to engine failure risk.

What makes the Twin Comanche different from single-engine aircraft?

The Piper Twin Comanche offers twin-engine redundancy, better performance at altitude, and ability to handle terrain better than single-engine alternatives. However, it requires higher pilot qualifications (multi-engine rating mandatory), more complex systems, higher fuel burn (16-17 GPH vs. 8-12 GPH for comparable singles), and significantly higher maintenance and insurance costs. Twin-engine aircraft are better for reliability-critical missions but cost 2-3x more to operate than singles.

Is the Twin Comanche suitable for cross-country flights?

The Piper Twin Comanche is excellent for cross-country flying with a 950-nautical-mile range (depending on payload and winds), cruise speed of 160-170 knots, and twin-engine reliability. It carries 4-5 occupants with reasonable fuel reserves and handles weather better than singles. However, the aircraft is 50-60 years old (production ended 1972), so reliability depends heavily on maintenance history. Many owners use the Twin Comanche for regular transportation, though turbocharging and known-icing capability are not available on most models.

What's the resale value of a Twin Comanche?

Piper Twin Comanche aircraft hold value reasonably well for vintage twins, with typical depreciation of 2-4% annually if properly maintained. A $165,000 aircraft might retain 50-60% of value over 10 years. However, the vintage market for 50+ year old aircraft is niche—they appeal primarily to pilots who value twin-engine experience and proven reliability. Major damage history, engine reserve status, and total airframe hours significantly impact resale value.

Ready to Finance Your Dream Aircraft?

Let Jaken Aviation help you secure competitive financing for your piston aircraft. Get started with a free consultation today.

Get Pre-Qualified Today